Discernment Counseling –
Time-Limited Help if Considering Divorce

Discernment counseling is a therapeutic approach designed for those who are struggling with the decision about whether to stay in a marriage, divorce or wait and do nothing. 

It’s sometimes called “pre-divorce counseling,” but if one of you is dead set on getting divorced, there is no question about it; this form of counseling isn’t for you. If one of you is seriously contemplating divorce or you’re a couple on the brink, this isn’t the time to “work on the marriage.” 

That time has passed.

“dis·cern·ment coun-sel-ing:” noun – A marital approach that increases your ability to judge your marital options well: Pre-divorce counseling: Couples seeking professional advice by a qualified mental health provider.

But if you have lingering doubts about whether getting divorced is the right move, you’ll want to slow down and give it some serious thought. You need a place where a seasoned professional can meet with you individually, and briefly together, to help you sort it out.

Have a place where the professional sees you short-term, individually, and briefly together. We do it over a weekend. It’s for mixed-agenda couples deciding whether to divorce or not.

Divorce is an impactful decision.

It’s an important one that only you can make, on your own. It doesn’t require agreement between you both.

So this is a time-limited approach that can help you judge your marital options well and to make the call with greater clarity and confidence—especially if one of you is seriously contemplating divorce.

Make sure that marriage counseling isn’t a waste of your time and money – and that you’re not jumping the gun on a divorce you might regret.




Discernment Counseling is for couples where at least one partner is actively doubtful that marital therapy will help.

Who goes to discernment counseling?

The leaning out partner’s perspective


You may be looking to “get out easy” without being the one everyone “blames” for the divorce or causing even more pain.

If you have done counseling before, you may have “agreed” halfheartedly. Secretly, you were utterly convinced that “nothing would help.” Or you went to someone you thought was an expert, and it went horribly.

Maybe you brought up counseling and it got shot down.

You could be involved in an undisclosed, ongoing extra-marital affair that you aren’t willing to reveal or to give up.

Or maybe you’re so depressed you can’t do therapy well.

The divorce process feels overwhelming, too.

Or you want a no-fault divorce, but you’re getting no cooperation.

Maybe there are children, and you’re worried about how this will affect them.

This might not be the first time you’ve thought about leaving.

But at this point, you can’t continue the way things are, not for your husband or wife, not for anybody, not even if kids are involved. You are in so much pain that you believe divorce may be the only solution.

You have a story to tell.

Pain, frustration. Maybe that story hasn’t been taken seriously – maybe not even now. It’s about your unhappiness. The efforts you put in. How little it helped.

The lonely feelings you’ve been covering up. How invisible you feel. And how the things you’ve done to try to make things better have just left you even more hopeless. You want to give up.

There’s no air in the room when you are together. Vacations suck. You feel like a big faker by staying. And you want a life. You deserve a life. The passion is gone (if it ever was there), and you don’t believe in keeping up appearances.

But Divorce? That’s A Big Step

You want a place to talk it out. To find the words. To explain to your spouse—who may be freaked out or so angry that you can’t even say “pass the salt” without a blow-up.

We’re not here to “convince” you to stay. Our job is to slow things down, and help you get clear—to yourself—about why you want what you want.

This isn’t marriage counseling. We aren’t going to try to transform your relationship.

Discernment counseling can save thousands of dollars spent on marital counseling doomed from the start.

If you decide to try couples therapy, that’s later. That’s one of three outcomes you’ll consider. But for now? You just want to know where you stand.

Let’s be honest: if you don’t explore your contributions to the problems, you’re just going to repeat them.

And if you’re actively having an affair (no, we won’t make you disclose it in Discernment Counseling…), repeating that pattern may come sooner than you think.

The ‘Leaning In’ spouse’s perspective

You knew there were problems, but leaving? That’s not what you thought the two of you were made of. You’re not a quitter. And now? YOu feel completely blindsided.

You’re going to leave?
Just like that?
After everything?
You’re walking out on me and the family?

Is there someone else? Really? Her? Him?

It’s hard to be your ‘best self’ in this moment Your hurt. Furious. Cold Shutting down. Or spinning. A whole mess of emotions.

You’re probably not putting your best foot forward.

The “leaning-in” partner usually feels like the rug has been ripped out from under them. Their spouse is saying, “I’m not in love with you anymore…” or worse, “I want a divorce.”

They’re angry. Grieving. Flailing. Some become abusive. Others placating, inconsolable, or willing to “do anything” to make it work. They may change moods by the hour.

But you’re not a “victim,” and you have work to do.

First, decide: Do you really want this marriage?

If so-why?

Get honest about what’s working—and what’s not.

Goals for the ‘Leaning Out’ partner

  • Clarity
  • Confidence
  • Ending the struggling deciding what is the best thing. Relief from the struggle of indecision.

What’s the format?

Discernment Counseling is short-term and structured.

Your therapist will meet primarily with each of you individually. In a weekend intensive, we’ll meet with each of you privately for about 90 minutes and briefly together between sessions.

This is not marriage counseling. There is no debating, blaming, or trying to fix anything during your joint sessions.

Remember: one of you is nearly out the door. The other may be ready to do whatever it takes.

There’s a lot to talk about. Calmly. Rationally. Seriously.

You’ll:

  • Explore how you got to this point
  • Evaluate whether past counseling helped or hurt
  • Examine your next steps

You need time, space, and a clear-headed therapist to help you make sense of it all.

And yes—it’s time-limited.

Can you own your part?

There are legitimate reasons to leave a marriage. But ask yourself:

  • Drug or alcohol abuse?
  • Periodic violence?
  • Explosive rage or untreated depression?
  • Multiple affairs on your part?
  • Or the quieter stuff-emotional or sexual neglect that’s gone on for years? Decades?

Discernment counseling isn’t a “pity party” for the partner who wants to stay. And it’s not just a stage for venting pain.

If you aren’t willing to hear what your partner is saying about why they want to leave, you might as well sign the divorce papers now.

If you’re the one ready to go, discernment counseling may be a single session to get clear on that and figure out how to move forward well.

If you want to stay, how you handle yourself from here on out matters. Threatening, shaming, pleading? None of that works.

Discernment Counseling is about bringing your best, clearest self—especially in private sessions.

Real. Concentrated. Work.

Goals for the Leaning In partner

  • Bring your best self forward
  • Get grounded—don’t escalate
  • Reduce the panic

Why Discernment Counseling?

Discernment Counseling is successful when both partners leave with clarity and confidence in their decision.

Once you’ve gained direction, you can move forward—toward divorce, reconciliation, or taking a pause before deciding—with greater purpose.

At Couples Therapy Inc., we start all Discernment Counseling with a State of the Union Assessment. We want to deeply understand what’s going on so we can help you better. Think of it as “pre-discernment counseling.”

What are the expected outcomes of discernment counseling?

Path One: Stay the same- Do nothing (and most people hate this).

Path Two: Make an informed, ideally mutual decision to divorce-perhaps with the support of a divorce mediator.

No pressure. You don’t have to choose now. But you do have to be honest—with yourself first.

Who Practices Discernment Counseling?

A highly trained, select group of professionals. Many have been approved by Dr. Bill Doherty, the method’s founder. These clinicians are experienced in high-stakes couples work and understand how to guide tough conversations with care and structure.

Discernment Counseling helps individuals within the couple decide whether therapy is even worth pursuing. Spoiler: sometimes, it’s not.

And that realization? It can save thousands in failed therapy attempts—and years of resentment.

Managing “the Audience”

If you haven’t told anyone about your situation yet—good. Hold off.

Once the cat’s out of the bag, everyone will have an opinion—and most won’t be neutral.

Unless your friends are trained Marital First Responders, they’re likely to push their own agendas, consciously or not.

You’re in the middle of an emotional hurricane. Let’s not make it worse.

Final Thoughts

No one wants half-hearted couples counseling. Not your therapist. Not your spouse. And certainly not you.

Discernment Counseling makes sure you don’t waste your time, money, or emotional bandwidth on therapy that isn’t right—or isn’t right yet.

We help each partner reflect deeply on their own contributions and explore all viable paths forward.

Even if you divorce, knowing what role you played will shape how you love in the future.

Closing

Making the choice between working on your marriage and moving toward divorce is one of life’s biggest decisions.

Discernment Counseling is a short-term, high-impact process that helps you make this decision with confidence and clarity.

Whether you try couples therapy, decide to separate, or simply take more time to reflect—you’ll leave knowing you’ve faced it with integrity.

There’s no “right” answer. Only your right answer.

Originally published February 23, 2016